Going with the Flow: Houston's Multifamily Market Adapts to Oil Drop
Steve Guggenmos, VP Research & Modeling
Two years ago, the oil and gas industry was booming in the United States with the price of oil over $100 a barrel. Houston was the nation’s number one creator of energy-related jobs and home to half of the 52 Texas-based firms on the annual list of the biggest U.S. companies (source: Houston Chronicle). Only three of those companies were not in the primary business of energy. It was also home to the largest share of multifamily units among energy-dependent markets.
Fast forward to 2016
As of this writing, West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude oil is around $37 a barrel. What has this dramatic drop done to Houston that has an economy closely tied to the energy sector? Intuitively, the weakening of the energy industry and the slowdown in the job market should have a huge impact on multifamily housing.
However, the impacts have yet to stop rent growth across the metro. Houston’s economy is fairly diversified despite the high concentration of energy-related jobs. As such, the overall strength in the U.S. economy helped the other sectors in Houston, like leisure and hospitality, education and health services, and retail trade, to offset the job losses in the energy-related sectors.
Better than forecasted
The broad apartment rental market has not yet been overwhelmed by the weakened oil industry. Vacancy rates last year remained flat for the first three quarters and ticked up only 10 basis points in the fourth quarter, according to REIS. Rent growth was lower than in 2014, but still higher than the historical average.
However, growth was not evenly distributed across Houston’s submarkets: areas on the west side of the market, where a large number of Class A multifamily units have been delivered in the past few years, experienced vacancy rate increases as much as 4.8 percentage points. The east side of the market, with lower supply and mostly Class B and C apartments, fared comparatively better.
Our full report (link below) considers a range of economic scenarios and forecasts the impact on Houston’s multifamily fundamentals. All scenarios project a slowdown in multifamily growth. Continued low oil prices would hinder growth over the next two years. If a U.S. recession were to happen, multifamily performance would deteriorate significantly. The likelihood of a recession is less probable, but even under this scenario Houston’s multifamily performance weakens, but will not reach the levels seen during the oil crisis of the early 1980s.
-
Feedback
Have a comment or question? Email us to let us know what's on your mind.
Viewpoints
-
Nov 7, 2019Don’t Stop Believing - 5 Years of SBL
-
Nov 4, 2019Clear Direction, Bright Future – Optigo 2019
-
Oct 7, 2019Strong and Steady - and Even Better
About This Author
Steve Guggenmos
VP Research & Modeling
Steve leads multifamily related research at Freddie Mac. In this role he performs research related to national and market-specific multifamily conditions. His team supports the multifamily business by developing models and quantitative approaches that determine risk-based capital allocations. The models capture loan level risks and also the benefits of the diversification and structural credit support for pools of multifamily mortgages, supporting the core business strategies of Freddie Mac Multifamily.
More From This Author
Multifamily 2019 Midyear Outlook
In our research, we find that strong economic growth and the robust labor market continue to support the strength in the multifamily market. 2018 ended much stronger than anticipated with near record absorptions and stronger rent growth compared with the prior few years.
The Diminishing Supply of Affordable Units
Recent research shows that an increasing number of multifamily units are not affordable for low- and very low-income households.
Assessing Rental Burden in Metropolitan Areas
Rental affordability is a significant challenge for metropolitan statistical areas across the United States. Our research shows that supply just hasn't kept pace with demand in many metros, and that's pushing affordable rents out of reach for millions of American families.
Multifamily 2019 Outlook
In our research, we find that performance in the multifamily market remained healthy during 2018, despite high levels of new supply entering the market. We expect this trend to continue into 2019, but with more modest growth in comparison to recent years.
Multifamily 2018 Mid-Year Outlook
Performance in the multifamily market remained healthy in the first half of 2018, and is expected to continue throughout the second half of 2018 and into 2019, but with continued moderation from the prior few years.
The Cost of Missing Out on LIHTC-Program Rents
Market rate multifamily rents have been dramatically increasing in recent years as housing demand significantly exceeds available supply. In contrast, during the same period rent growth has been moderate for units with restricted rents, such as those funded by the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) program.
How Do I Envision the Multifamily Market in 2018?
More of the same! By most measures, the multifamily market will continue to grow with moderately increasing demand, with the growing population fueling the rental housing market.
Outlook Remains Positive for the Remainder of 2017
Through the first half of 2017, the economy's growth continued to support strong multifamily fundamentals, while the market continued to moderate on a national level.
Will 2017 Be Another Growth Year?
Steve Guggenmos, Vice President, Research and Modeling, provides the answer.
2016 Mid-Year Outlook: Where Are We Heading?
By the end of 2015, the multifamily industry was closing out five years of an unprecedented run of success. Are we slowing down?
Rental Demand Still Going Strong
Millennials moving out of their parents homes and aging baby boomers are increasing the number of older renters, making rental demand strong.
Outlook 2016: The Momentum Continues
The multifamily market accelerated in 2015 and will build on that momentum this year.
Rental Housing Demand Surges, Confirms Importance of Our Workforce Housing
'The decade-long surge in rental demand is unprecedented;' according to a Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University (JCHS) report released December 9.
New Market Outlook Sees Robust Growth Continuing
The multifamily markets winning streak will continue for the next few years, we found in our latest research. The Multifamily Outlook Second Half 2015 reports our findings and the details behind them.
Small Properties Present Big Opportunities, New Research Finds
Close to one-third of renters live in smaller properties with five to 50 units, many of which are affordable to low- and very low-income households. Given the importance of this housing segment, our latest Multifamily Research Perspectives report examines lending aimed at smaller properties...
JCHS Study: Multifamily Fundamentals Stay Strong, Renter Pressures Increase
The Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University recently released its annual The State of the Nation's Housing report. It's an interesting read with plenty of useful information for those of us in housing finance.
Will Austin and Nashville Keep Topping the Charts?
Austin and Nashville - two great music cities, two strong economies, both with strong multifamily markets since the Great Recession.
How Will Oil Prices Impact Multifamily Housing?
With summer vacation season upon us and gas prices lower per gallon than a year ago, the benefits of lower oil prices to consumers are apparent.
What Will 2015 Bring For Multifamily Markets?
We just released our Multifamily economic outlook for 2015. The forecast is for another strong year, albeit at lower levels than in 2014.